The Sandlot 2 (2005)

by Linda Kay

Directed by: David Mickey Evans

Cat Out of the Bag Alert! This review contains some spoilers for this film!

Synopsis: This sad attempt to try to recreate the spark of the original Sandlot movie is set in the year 1972, ten years after the events in the last film took place and follows the basic steps of the first film, only this time with girls included.

Cat Burglars (Scene Stealers): Having chased off space-enthusiast Johnnie Smalls (James Wilson) after he launches one of his model rockets in the lot, the boys end up in the yard of Hayley Goodfairer (Samantha Burton) who will eventually turn out to have a mean pitching arm. As she protects Smalls by demanding the other boys leave her yard, she picks up a longhair tabby and white cat named Miss Susan B. (after Susan B. Anthony, since Hayley and her mother are both feminists).

The Sandlot 2 - longhair tabby and white cat Miss Susan B. rubbing against legs
The Sandlot 2 - Hayley Samantha Burton holding longhair tabby and white cat Miss Susan B. with Johnnie Smalls James Wilson

The boys realize the rocket has set their clubhouse on fire and beg Hayley to borrow her hose. Eventually she agrees.

The Sandlot 2 - Hayley Samantha Burton holding longhair tabby and white cat Miss Susan B.

Hayley and Smalls watch the boys attempt to put out the fire as she tells Smalls to return the next day, explaining that since she saved his life he has to do whatever she says.

The Sandlot 2 - Hayley Samantha Burton holding longhair tabby and white cat Miss Susan B. with Johnnie Smalls James Wilson
The Sandlot 2 - Hayley Samantha Burton holding longhair tabby and white cat Miss Susan B. with Johnnie Smalls James Wilson

The leader of the boys, David Durango (Max Lloyd-Jones) has a crush on Hayley and watches as she returns to her yard with the kitty.

The Sandlot 2 - Hayley Samantha Burton holding longhair tabby and white cat Miss Susan B.
The Sandlot 2 - Hayley Samantha Burton holding longhair tabby and white cat Miss Susan B. while flirting with David Max Lloyd-Jones animated gif

Later in the film when the boys are trying to retrieve Hayley’s father’s space shuttle model from the yard of “The Great Fear” (the same kind of scary dog as in the first movie), Hayley’s friends come up with the idea of using Miss Susan B. They hook the cat into a sling to ride across to the shuttle with the idea that she will hook the rocket with her claws and bring it back once the dog adequately scares her.

The Sandlot 2 - longhair tabby and white cat Miss Susan B. in sling
The Sandlot 2 - longhair tabby and white cat Miss Susan B. in sling
The Sandlot 2 - longhair tabby and white cat Miss Susan B. swinging across yard on sling directed by Smalls James Wilson animated gif

This of course does not go as planned and the dog comes face to face with the poor cat.

The Sandlot 2 - longhair tabby and white cat Miss Susan B. in sling face to face with giant dog
The Sandlot 2 - longhair tabby and white cat Miss Susan B. hissing

We see fur flying and when they reel in Miss Susan B. she is a hairless Sphynx cat.

The Sandlot 2 - Sphynx cat in sling
The Sandlot 2 - close up of Sphynx cat meowing

The animal coordinator on the film was Bonnie Judd from Canine Co-Stars of Canada Ltd. The animal trainers were Ashley Suttle and Ryan Judd.

The Sandlot 2 - Sphynx cat being pulled up by sling and making kids scream animated gif

Final Mewsings: Even back then using a Sphynx for this kind of joke was already getting old.

Many thanks to Ricco for letting us know about the cats in this film!

Relevant Links:

IMDb logo
Amazon logo
Amazon Instant Video logo




To discuss this film and other cats in movies and on television, join us on Facebook and X.