A Girl Must Live (1939)

by Mark Murton

Directed by: Carol Reed

Cat Out of the Bag Alert! This review contains some spoilers for this film!

Synopsis: Fast paced farce in which two gold-digging chorus girls, Gloria (Renee Houston) and Clytie (Lilli Palmer), pursue eligible bachelor the Earl of Pangborough (Hugh Sinclair) but find they have competition from fellow chorus girl, the shy and demure Leslie (Margaret Lockwood).

Cat Burglar (Scene Stealer): The three girls win places in the chorus line of a new musical, and Gloria and Clytie attend the opening night party that follows, while Leslie returns to the boarding house where they all reside. Pangborough is also at the party and Gloria and Clytie waste no time vying for his attention, resulting in Gloria “accidentally” spilling wine on Clytie who immediately seizes the opportunity to have Pangborough drive her back to the boarding house so she can change. While Pangborough waits in the corridor outside Clytie’s room (which she shares with Gloria) he sees Leslie leaving her room and going down the stairs only to return a few seconds later holding a large grey Persian cat in her arms.

A Girl Must Live - Leslie Margaret Lockwood walking up stairs carrying gray Persian cat Jennie

At the top of the stairs, Leslie feigns surprise at Pangborough’s presence and drops the cat which runs off back down the stairs.

A Girl Must Live - Leslie Margaret Lockwood dropping gray Persian cat Jennie with Pangborough Hugh Sinclair
A Girl Must Live - gray Persian cat Jennie running down stairs

Leslie explains that she wanted the cat, Jennie, to catch a mouse she found in her room, so Pangborough volunteers to help her reclaim the cat. They make their way down to the kitchen as Leslie urges Pangborough to make as little noise as possible to avoid disturbing the other residents. Arriving in the kitchen, they find Jennie sitting on the sill by the open window. As they creep towards her, Jennie jumps down out of the window into the back yard.

A Girl Must Live - Leslie Margaret Lockwood looking at gray Persian cat Jennie with Pangborough Hugh Sinclair

Purr Blur: Leslie and Pangborough go out into the yard where they spy Jennie sitting on the shed roof next to a black cat.

A Girl Must Live - gray Persian cat Jennie on top of roof with black cat

Pangborough climbs up to try and reach Jennie (the other cat having already disappeared), noisily knocking over various objects on the way, much to Leslie’s consternation.

A Girl Must Live - Leslie Margaret Lockwood watching gray Persian cat Jennie on roof with Pangborough Hugh Sinclair

Inevitably, just as Pangborough reaches Jennie she runs off across the roof – cue further crashing about which starts the chickens in the yard clucking loudly as well as the dog there barking incessantly.

A Girl Must Live - gray Persian cat Jennie running away from Pangborough Hugh Sinclair

To add to the mayhem, Clytie, continuing to talk to Pangborough who she thinks is still outside the door, finally reacts to the racket outside by throwing a shoe (one of Gloria’s, naturally) in the direction of the commotion. The shoe hits Pangborough, allowing Jennie to scurry off again. Eventually Pangborough manages to gather up Jennie and they all go back inside.

A Girl Must Live - Leslie Margaret Lockwood with gray Persian cat Jennie carried by Pangborough Hugh Sinclair
A Girl Must Live - Leslie Margaret Lockwood with gray Persian cat Jennie carried by Pangborough Hugh Sinclair

Pangborough carries Jennie into Leslie’s room and sets her down near the closet where Leslie says the mouse is.

A Girl Must Live - Leslie Margaret Lockwood with gray Persian cat Jennie being set on chair by Pangborough Hugh Sinclair

Meanwhile, Gloria has arrived back at the boarding house and once she and Clytie have finished trading insults they realise Pangborough has disappeared. Hearing Leslie and Pangborough laughing in her room they burst in to see what’s happening and are greeted by the site of Leslie lying on the bed looking underneath it as Pangborough emerges holding Jennie.

A Girl Must Live - Leslie Margaret Lockwood on bed with gray Persian cat Jennie held by Pangborough Hugh Sinclair

Leslie explains about the mouse to the sceptical Gloria and Clytie as they continue their bickering. Pangborough ends the feuding, temporarily at least, by making his excuses and leaving, passing Jennie to Leslie as he goes.

A Girl Must Live - Leslie Margaret Lockwood and Clytie Lilli Palmer with gray Persian cat Jennie held by Pangborough Hugh Sinclair
A Girl Must Live - Leslie Margaret Lockwood and Clytie Lilli Palmer with gray Persian cat Jennie held by Pangborough Hugh Sinclair

Leslie, a picture of innocence, sits on the bed cradling Jennie in her arms as she declares, “I can’t think what happened to that mouse, he seems to have got away.”

A Girl Must Live - Leslie Margaret Lockwood with gray Persian cat Jennie on bed

“Funny there are mice in a house,” responds Gloria pointedly, “where there are so many cats about.”

A Girl Must Live - Leslie Margaret Lockwood with gray Persian cat Jennie on bed
A Girl Must Live - Leslie Margaret Lockwood holding gray Persian cat Jennie publicity still

A cat lover in real life, Margaret Lockwood is pictured here with her own cat (circa 1953).

A Girl Must Live - Leslie Margaret Lockwood holding up pet tabby cat

And again at home with her daughter and another family cat.

A Girl Must Live - Leslie Margaret Lockwood with daughter holding bicolor tabby cat at home

Final Mewsings: Is it cheating to employ a cat in the pursuit of love?

Relevant Links:

IMDb logo
tcmlogo




To discuss this film and other cats in movies and on television, join us on Facebook and Twitter.

Share this with your cat and movie loving friends!