Post updated March 27, 2026

Directed by: John Cromwell

This review contains a Severe Kitty Carnage Warning!

Synopsis: A hard-biting drama about a nineteen-year-old girl named Marie Allen (Eleanor Parker) who finds herself in prison after her young husband attempts to rob a gas station with her in tow. She desperately struggles to play it straight and obey the rules until she can obtain an early parole, but an unexpected pregnancy, a viciously cruel matron (Hope Emerson) and countless setbacks threaten to turn her into a hardened criminal, despite the best efforts of the sympathetic prison head (Agnes Moorehead.)

Cat Burglar (Scene Stealer): One night when Marie Allen is returning to the cell block she finds a tiny tabby kitten mewing in the frost-covered bushes.

She sneaks the animal inside, catching the attention of her fellow inmates as she explains she plans to keep the wee baby as a pet. Naming the kitten Fluff (Marie Allen plays it safe with the name since she doesn’t know the kitten’s sex), the tiny stray quickly steals the hearts of every female inmate.

Having stashed Fluff in Marie Allen’s foot locker, the women return to the cell and give the baby some milk they’ve smuggled in.

It is impossible to overstate just how powerful this scene is with the women all sitting in complete silence and every eye focused on the tiny kitten lapping milk.

It is sadly predictable from the moment that Marie Allen finds the kitten that it will come to no good end, and unfortunately that ominous prediction comes to fruition. During a routine head count the matron hears Fluff mewing and demands the cat be turned over or else.

Marie Allen retrieves Fluff from her locker but clings to the kitten desperately, even when the matron starts to advance on her.

The girl push the beds together to stall the matron long enough for Marie Allen to run. As she scoots along the beds she pauses to tuck Fluff inside a pillowcase before an all-out brawl breaks out.

Severe Kitty Carnage Warning! After the prison guards are able to bring the inmates under control, Marie Allen looks for Fluff. Unfortunately, she finds the poor kitten dead, having been inadventently killed during the violence. Even Agnes Moorehead shows no sympathy and tells Marie Allen she must be punished and put into solitary confinement. “All I wanted was the kitten,” Marie Allen sighs sadly.

The scene in which she finds the kitten dead after the girl’s riot is not only heartbreaking but a bit disturbing, since the kitten really does appear to be dead. But if you look closely you can just barely see the kitten’s mouth move for a moment. We can only hope the kitten was simply sedated to appear dead (not that doing so is an acceptable practice, but perhaps better than the alternative.)

This specific issue does not seem to have been addressed in any newspaper articles back in the day (that we could find, anyway) but the kitten’s scenes were notable enough to be mentioned in just about every review of the film. Several small blurbs about the cat actor playing the part were shared in various publications, starting with this entry from The Daily Standard Freeholder on October 22, 1949:

    Burbank, Calif — casting a kitten can be almost as painful as choosing an actress for a part, learned director John Cromwell when he tried to find a kitten with just the right personality to cause a riot in Warner Bros.’ women’s prison picture, “Caged,” starring Eleanor Parker. He had to interview twenty-five felines before he found the right one. Fifteen of them scratched him.

Even the sex of the kitten proved to be important, according to this snippet in The News from October 12, 1949:

    Just to keep everything in the proper mood, director John Cromwell insisted on casting a female kitten for an important role in “Caged,” which features a cast of 39 women, headed by Eleanor Parker. The casting proved pretty painful as Cromwell had to interview 25 felines before he found the right one.

Photos of actress Eleanor Parker as her character Marie Allen were also printed in various newspapers to promote the release of the movie.

Final Mewsings: Fluff belonged in jail for being a complete scene stealer!

Relevant Links:

To discuss this film and other cats in movies and on television, join us on Facebook and X.